Addressing The Criticism: Disney's Changes To The Snow White Remake

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.7

Share

The Casting of Rachel Zegler as Snow White

Controversy Surrounding the Choice

The casting of Rachel Zegler as Snow White ignited a significant backlash online. Many critics voiced concerns, framing the choice as "politically correct casting," arguing it prioritized diversity over faithfulness to the original character's depiction. Conversely, many praised the casting as a progressive step towards more inclusive representation in Disney films.

• Online Discussions: Numerous forums and social media platforms saw heated debates, with users expressing strong opinions both for and against Zegler's selection. Articles across various news outlets detailed the controversy, highlighting the divided opinions of the audience.
• Arguments For: Supporters emphasized the importance of diverse representation in children's media, arguing that a Latina Snow White broadens the scope of the character and provides positive representation for a wider demographic.
• Arguments Against: Critics claimed that deviating from the traditional depiction of Snow White undermines the integrity of the original story and caters to modern political agendas rather than artistic merit.

Addressing the "Deviance" from the Original

Zegler's portrayal promises a significant departure from previous Snow White iterations. While past versions often depicted Snow White as a passive damsel, Zegler's Snow White is depicted as more proactive and independent. This modern interpretation aims to present a more empowered female lead.

• Character Arc Comparison: Unlike the traditionally passive Snow White of the animated film, early promotional material suggests a more assertive and independent character in this adaptation. This contrasts sharply with Disney's 1937 version and even other live-action interpretations.
• Nuanced and Empowered Snow White: The remake seemingly intends to modernize the character, giving her agency and a stronger personality, thereby addressing criticism of the original's portrayal of a passive, almost helpless heroine. This update aims to resonate with modern audiences.

Changes to the Storyline and Character Arcs

Modernizing the Narrative

The live-action remake features substantial alterations to the original plot. While specific details are still emerging, trailers and reported plot points suggest significant changes to the narrative. These modifications aim to make the story more relevant to contemporary audiences.

• Significant Plot Changes: Reported changes include a shift in the focus of certain plot points and a potential reimagining of the roles of supporting characters. The classic fairytale elements are being reinterpreted for a modern context.
• Updated Social Context: Disney's goal appears to be to modernize the narrative by addressing outdated tropes and social norms. This includes potentially reimagining certain relationships and character motivations to align with current social sensibilities.

The Prince's Diminished Role and the "Toxic Masculinity" Debate

One of the most debated changes involves the Prince's character. Critics argue that reducing his role reflects a trend towards de-emphasizing the traditional "prince charming" archetype, often associated with toxic masculinity.

• Alterations to the Prince's Role: Early reports suggest that the Prince's character will have a significantly less prominent role in the film, shifting the narrative focus towards Snow White's journey of self-discovery and empowerment.
• Shifting Focus to Female Empowerment: This change is seen by some as a positive step toward portraying healthier relationships and promoting female empowerment, while others argue it alters the fundamental dynamic of the original story.

The Seven Dwarfs' Portrayal and Inclusivity Concerns

Controversy Surrounding the Dwarfs' Representation

The portrayal of the Seven Dwarfs has generated perhaps the most intense debate. Reports suggest significant changes to their representation, sparking concerns among some audiences. The changes are intended to address concerns about outdated portrayals.

• Criticisms and Arguments: Many criticized the changes as pandering to modern sensibilities, potentially compromising the integrity of the original story and its unique characters. Conversely, some believe the changes are necessary to avoid perpetuating potentially offensive stereotypes. Specific alterations include changing the portrayal of the dwarfs.
• Inclusivity and Representation Debate: This controversy highlights the ongoing debate within children’s media regarding inclusivity and the need to carefully consider the potential impact of representations on young audiences.

Balancing Modernization with Authenticity

Disney faces the complex challenge of adapting a classic fairytale to a modern audience while respecting the original source material. This necessitates carefully navigating the line between updating the story for contemporary viewers and preserving its essential elements.

• Balancing Act: Disney’s approach attempts to modernize certain aspects of the narrative and character portrayals while retaining the core elements of the original story. The success of this balancing act remains to be seen.
• Challenges of Adaptation: Adapting classic fairytales to modern sensibilities is inherently challenging, often leading to criticisms from those who prefer the original versions. The inherent conflict between nostalgia and modernization is at the heart of this controversy.

Conclusion

Disney's Snow White remake has faced considerable criticism, centered around the casting of Rachel Zegler, significant storyline alterations, and particularly the revised portrayal of the Seven Dwarfs. These changes, intended to modernize the classic fairytale and promote inclusivity, have elicited both praise and condemnation, highlighting the diverse perspectives and complex considerations involved in adapting beloved classics for a modern audience. The debate reflects differing views on the balance between respecting the source material and catering to modern sensibilities.

What are your thoughts on the changes made to Disney’s Snow White remake? Share your opinion in the comments below and join the conversation on Disney's Snow White Remake Criticism.