John Wick 4's Low Rotten Tomatoes Score: A Critical Analysis Of The Fan Favorite

Luna Greco

6 min read

Post on May 12, 2025

4.0

Share

The Action Sequences: Too Much of a Good Thing?

One potential explanation for the lower-than-expected John Wick 4 Rotten Tomatoes score lies in the sheer volume and intensity of its action sequences. While undeniably impressive, could the sheer amount of action have led to a sense of fatigue for some critics?

Over-the-top action and diminishing returns:

• Excessively Long Fight Scenes: Several fight sequences, though brilliantly choreographed, stretched on for extended periods, potentially leading to a feeling of repetition and diminishing returns for some viewers. The extended fight in the Arc de Triomphe, while visually stunning, might have tested the patience of critics looking for more narrative pacing.
• Pacing Issues: The relentless action, while visually captivating, might have overshadowed other narrative elements, creating pacing issues that detracted from the overall viewing experience for certain critics. The focus remained heavily on the spectacle, potentially at the cost of narrative flow.
• Repetitive Action Beats: While innovative in many ways, some critics may have found repetitive elements within the action choreography itself, lessening the impact of the sheer volume of fight sequences. The constant use of gun-fu, while effective, might have felt formulaic to some viewers.
• Genre Fatigue: Critics, constantly exposed to action films, may experience a degree of genre fatigue, making them more critical of even highly polished action sequences. The saturation of the market with similar films could lead to higher expectations, making even exceptional work seem less groundbreaking.

Innovation vs. Repetition:

While the action in John Wick 4 was undeniably impressive, did it sufficiently innovate compared to its predecessors?

• Comparison with Previous Films: While building on the established gun-fu style, some critics might have felt that John Wick 4 didn't significantly advance the action choreography in a way that justified its length. The formula, while effective, felt familiar to some.
• Unique Action Set Pieces: While the film boasts incredible action set pieces – the Arc de Triomphe fight being a prime example – some might argue that the overall innovation wasn't substantial enough to warrant the extended runtime dedicated to action.
• Action Serving the Narrative: A key question is whether the extensive action sequences effectively served the narrative. Some critics might argue that the film prioritized spectacle over narrative, diminishing the overall impact.

Narrative Structure and Character Development:

Beyond the action, another factor contributing to John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes score might be the narrative structure and character development.

Simple Plot and Character Arcs:

• Analysis of Plot Points: The plot, while functional, was arguably relatively straightforward compared to other action films, potentially lacking the complexity or unexpected twists that some critics might have desired.
• Assessment of Character Arcs: While the main characters are well-defined, the arcs of both John Wick and his adversaries may not have been significantly developed in this installment.
• Comparison to Previous Films: Compared to previous films, some critics may have found John Wick 4's narrative less compelling and character development less profound.

Focus on spectacle over substance:

• Emphasis on Action over Character Development: The overwhelming emphasis on action sequences might have overshadowed character development, potentially leaving some critics wanting more depth and emotional connection with the characters.
• Plot Sacrificed for Visual Effects: In prioritizing breathtaking visual effects, some argue that crucial plot elements were sacrificed or underdeveloped, leading to narrative inconsistencies and a sense of incompleteness.
• Overall Narrative Effectiveness: The effectiveness of the narrative in carrying the weight of the film’s extended runtime was a key point of discussion amongst critics. The argument was raised that despite the compelling action, the story did not meet the same high standard.

The Role of Audience Expectations and Fandom:

The immense popularity of the John Wick franchise significantly impacts both audience and critical reception.

The Power of Fan Expectations:

• Pre-release Buzz: The significant pre-release buzz surrounding John Wick 4 undoubtedly created high expectations among fans. This hype could have influenced both positive audience reactions and stricter critical assessments.
• Expectations Based on Previous Films: The high bar set by the previous John Wick films influenced audience expectations. Any perceived deviation from the established formula, even if intentional, could have been met with criticism from fans used to specific elements in previous installments.
• Impact on Critical Assessments: The expectations surrounding the film likely influenced how critics approached their reviews. A film carrying so much anticipation might be judged more critically than a lesser-known film, regardless of its quality.

The "Fan Favorite" Factor:

• Influence of the Franchise's Popularity: The immense popularity of the franchise could have created an inherent bias, both amongst fans and some critics. Positive reviews from fans are expected, yet critics face pressure to approach the film objectively.
• Critical Resistance to Popular Films: There's often a degree of critical resistance to immensely popular films, leading to more stringent evaluations from some reviewers. Critics might feel compelled to provide alternative viewpoints, even if the film is well-received by the wider public.
• Bias Against Action Films: A prevalent critical bias exists towards action films, often leading to stricter assessments compared to other genres. Critics may focus more on narrative flaws and less on other merits.

Conclusion: Reconciling Critics and Fans – A Final Verdict on John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes Score

The discrepancy between John Wick 4's audience and critical reception highlights a complex interplay of factors. The film’s relentless action, while spectacular, may have led to pacing issues and a sense of repetition for some critics. The relatively simple plot and character development, arguably prioritizing spectacle over substance, further contributed to the divided opinion. Finally, the immense fan anticipation and inherent biases surrounding popular action films likely influenced both audience enthusiasm and critical scrutiny.

Ultimately, John Wick 4 remains a visually stunning and action-packed cinematic experience, even with its critical inconsistencies. The question of whether the film succeeds as a narrative piece remains subjective, with the film's strengths and weaknesses varying depending on individual preferences and expectations.

What are your thoughts on John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes score? Share your opinions and engage in a discussion on John Wick 4 review, John Wick 4 critical analysis, or John Wick 4 audience score in the comments section below!