John Wick 5: Why Another Movie Would Be A Mistake

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on May 12, 2025

4.0

Share

The Law of Diminishing Returns: Why More Isn't Always Better

The concept of diminishing returns is well-established in various fields, and the film industry is no exception. Sequels, while often lucrative, carry a significant risk of losing the initial impact and appeal that made the original successful. This is particularly true for action franchises heavily reliant on innovative action choreography and a compelling narrative.

• Sequels can lose their initial impact and appeal: The surprise and freshness of the first John Wick film are difficult to replicate. Each subsequent film has faced the challenge of topping its predecessor, leading to a potential decline in critical acclaim and audience enthusiasm.
• Repetitive plots and storylines can become stale: While the John Wick films have maintained a consistent level of quality, the risk of plot repetition and a lack of significant narrative innovation in a fifth installment is real. The audience might start to feel a sense of "déjà vu," diminishing the overall enjoyment.
• Examples of other franchises that suffered from over-sequelisation: Many successful franchises have fallen victim to over-saturation. Consider the Pirates of the Caribbean or Fast & Furious series. While initially successful, later installments faced criticism for declining quality and diminishing returns at the box office. For instance, a study by Box Office Mojo showed a consistent downward trend in average box office gross per film in several action franchises after the fourth installment.
• Box office decline: A study by Forbes highlighted that after a certain number of sequels, many action franchises experience a significant decrease in box office revenue, especially compared to the returns of earlier films in the franchise.

Story Exhaustion: Where Do We Go From Here?

The current John Wick narrative feels relatively complete. While the ending of John Wick: Chapter 4 leaves room for interpretation, it also provides a satisfying conclusion to the arc of John Wick's journey. Adding another film risks diluting this carefully constructed narrative.

• Potential for plot holes and inconsistencies: Adding another chapter risks introducing plot holes or inconsistencies that undermine the established lore and carefully crafted world. The more sequels, the harder it is to maintain consistency and coherence.
• Maintaining high-stakes action and intrigue: The action sequences in the John Wick films are a key component of their appeal. Maintaining the same level of innovative and exciting action in a fifth film presents a considerable creative challenge. Repeating similar fight styles could lead to a sense of fatigue.
• A complete narrative arc: The current narrative arc, centered around John Wick's revenge and his battles against the High Table, seems to have reached its natural conclusion. Introducing new conflicts might feel contrived and forced, detracting from the overall story.
• Diluting the impact of the existing narrative: A poorly conceived John Wick 5 could diminish the impact and resonance of the preceding films, undermining the overall legacy of the franchise.

The Risk of Compromising Quality for Quantity

The pressure to deliver a fifth installment quickly could compromise the quality of the film. This risk is particularly relevant considering the intricate action sequences and complex narrative that define the John Wick franchise.

• Increased pressure on writers and directors: Rushed production could lead to subpar writing, less innovative action choreography, and potentially weaker performances.
• Poorer quality writing, acting, and stunt work: Cutting corners to meet deadlines can significantly impact the final product, jeopardizing the reputation of the entire franchise.
• Impact on the franchise's overall reputation: A poorly received John Wick 5 could overshadow the positive reception of the previous films, tarnishing the legacy of the entire series.
• Damaging the legacy of the first four films: The risk of a poorly made fifth film overshadowing the success of the previous films is substantial. This could damage the franchise’s positive reputation and diminish its long-term appeal.

Financial Considerations: Is Another Film Financially Justifiable?

While a John Wick 5 might generate significant box office revenue initially, the potential for financial loss should be carefully considered. The production costs for these films are substantial, and the diminishing returns seen in similar franchises indicate that the potential profits might not outweigh the risks.

• Box office projections: Predicting the box office performance of a fifth film is challenging, especially given the potential for diminishing returns. Realistic projections should consider the performance of previous installments, and potential audience fatigue.
• Production costs: The high production costs associated with creating a high-quality action film like John Wick are significant. These costs, coupled with potential lower box office returns, increase the risk of financial loss.
• Potential for financial loss versus profit: A thorough cost-benefit analysis is essential to determine if the potential financial gains of a fifth film justify the significant risks involved.

Conclusion

While the John Wick franchise has achieved phenomenal success, a fifth installment carries considerable risks. The potential for diminishing returns, narrative exhaustion, and compromised quality are substantial concerns. Instead of pursuing John Wick 5, let's celebrate the existing four films, acknowledging the stylish action and compelling characters that defined this remarkable cinematic universe. Let's protect the legacy of this fantastic action franchise and avoid a sequel that could potentially harm its well-earned reputation. Let's appreciate the John Wick quadrilogy for the masterpiece it is, and resist the temptation of a potentially damaging John Wick 5.