Singer Benson Boone Denies Copying Harry Styles

Luna Greco

4 min read

Post on May 09, 2025

4.5

Share

The Viral Comparisons: What Sparked the Controversy?

The recent surge in comparisons between Benson Boone and Harry Styles' music stemmed from a series of viral videos circulating primarily on TikTok and YouTube. These videos, often presented as side-by-side comparisons, highlighted perceived similarities in vocal tone, melodic phrasing, and even certain stylistic choices in their performances. The rapid spread of these videos on social media platforms ignited a heated debate, with many users weighing in on whether Boone's work constituted plagiarism or simply reflected shared influences within a specific musical genre.

• Example 1: A widely shared TikTok video juxtaposed a section of Boone's "In the Stars" with a portion of Styles' "Watermelon Sugar," pointing out similar vocal runs and melodic contours.
• Example 2: Numerous comments on YouTube videos featuring Boone's performances echoed the sentiment of the TikTok videos, with users questioning the originality of his style. Some comments went as far as to accuse Boone of deliberate imitation.
• Example 3: Analysis of Boone and Styles' vocal techniques revealed similarities in their use of vibrato and breath control, further fueling the comparisons. However, critical analyses also highlighted significant differences in their overall vocal timbres and approaches to phrasing.

Benson Boone's Official Response and Denial

Facing mounting accusations of plagiarism, Benson Boone released an official statement on his social media platforms, vehemently denying any intentional copying of Harry Styles' music. His response emphasized his unique artistic vision and influences, while acknowledging the existence of certain stylistic overlaps within the broader pop genre. The tone of his statement was largely defensive but also conciliatory, attempting to address concerns without fueling further controversy.

• Summary of Boone's Key Arguments: Boone primarily argued that the perceived similarities stemmed from shared genre influences and the natural evolution of musical styles. He highlighted his unique songwriting process and cited diverse musical inspirations that extended beyond Styles' work.
• Specific Points Addressed: While he didn't address each comparison individually, Boone’s statement generally refuted claims of direct copying, suggesting the similarities were coincidental or derived from broader musical trends.
• Links to Official Statements: [Insert links to Boone's official statement or relevant social media posts if available].

Analyzing the Musical Similarities and Differences

A deeper analysis reveals both similarities and striking differences between Benson Boone and Harry Styles' music. While superficial similarities in vocal style and certain melodic choices exist – possibly influenced by shared genre trends within contemporary pop music – a closer examination showcases distinct characteristics in their respective artistic expressions. Both artists draw inspiration from classic rock and pop, but their individual interpretations and stylistic choices ultimately differ.

• Shared Genre Influences: Both artists operate within the contemporary pop landscape, drawing inspiration from classic rock and 70s soft rock elements. This shared foundation could explain some apparent stylistic overlaps.
• Comparison of Songwriting Techniques and Lyrical Themes: While both employ relatable lyrical themes in their songwriting, their approaches to storytelling and lyrical structure differ significantly. Boone's songwriting often leans towards more introspective and melancholic themes, while Styles tends towards more upbeat and celebratory ones.
• Highlighting Unique Elements of Each Artist's Style: Boone's voice has a distinctive rasp and emotional depth, which is noticeably different from Styles' smoother, more polished vocal style. Their songwriting approaches and instrumental arrangements also showcase unique personalities.

The Importance of Artistic Inspiration vs. Plagiarism

The line between artistic inspiration and plagiarism can be blurry, especially in music where influences and shared stylistic elements are inevitable. However, the crucial difference lies in the intent and execution. Drawing inspiration from other artists is a fundamental aspect of the creative process, but directly copying or mimicking another artist's work without proper attribution constitutes plagiarism and potential copyright infringement. The legal and ethical considerations surrounding musical similarities require careful evaluation on a case-by-case basis.

Conclusion

The Benson Boone and Harry Styles comparison highlights the complexities of artistic influence and originality in the music industry. While superficial similarities sparked a viral controversy, a nuanced analysis reveals distinct musical styles and creative approaches. Boone's denial underscores the importance of distinguishing between inspiration and outright plagiarism. Ultimately, critical listening and thoughtful consideration are crucial in navigating such comparisons. What are your thoughts on the Benson Boone and Harry Styles comparison? Share your perspective in the comments below!