Why School Suspensions Are Detrimental: A Critical Analysis

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on May 02, 2025

4.4

Share

The Academic Impact of School Suspensions

School suspensions significantly disrupt a student's learning journey, leading to a cascade of negative academic consequences. The immediate impact is often overlooked, but the long-term effects on academic performance are profound.

Increased Absenteeism and Falling Grades

Suspensions directly translate to missed classes, resulting in a gap in learning that is difficult to bridge. Students often fall behind their peers, struggle to complete assignments, and consequently experience a decline in their grades. The consequences are stark:

• Missed assignments and tests: Suspended students miss crucial instruction and assessment opportunities, making it challenging to catch up on missed material.
• Difficulty catching up: Even with extra help, the workload of catching up can be overwhelming, leading to further frustration and academic setbacks.
• Negative impact on GPA: Repeated suspensions directly correlate with a lower GPA, potentially impacting future educational and career opportunities. Understanding the correlation between school suspension rates and academic performance is crucial for developing effective interventions.

Higher Dropout Rates

The connection between school suspensions and higher dropout rates is well-documented. Suspension can be a significant predictor of a student leaving school before graduation. This is often part of a vicious cycle:

• Statistics on dropout rates among suspended students: Research consistently shows a higher dropout rate among students who have experienced multiple suspensions.
• The cycle of suspension and dropping out: Repeated suspensions can lead to feelings of disengagement and alienation from school, increasing the likelihood of dropping out.
• Long-term effects of suspension: The consequences of dropping out extend far beyond the immediate loss of education, impacting future earning potential and overall life opportunities. The long-term effects of suspension on at-risk students are especially concerning.

The Social-Emotional Impact of School Suspensions

Beyond the academic repercussions, school suspensions inflict significant damage on a student's social-emotional well-being. The emotional consequences can be devastating and long-lasting.

Damage to Self-Esteem and Mental Health

Suspension often leads to feelings of shame, isolation, and worthlessness. Students may experience:

• Emotional distress: The experience of suspension can be profoundly traumatic, leading to anxiety, depression, and feelings of hopelessness.
• Increased anxiety and depression: The social stigma associated with suspension can exacerbate existing mental health issues or trigger new ones.
• Potential for self-harm: In extreme cases, the emotional distress caused by suspension can increase the risk of self-harm or suicidal ideation. Understanding the link between school suspension and mental health is crucial for providing appropriate support.

Increased Risk of Involvement in the Juvenile Justice System

A troubling correlation exists between school suspensions and involvement with the juvenile justice system. This contributes to the school-to-prison pipeline:

• Statistics on the correlation: Data reveals a strong link between repeated suspensions and increased likelihood of contact with law enforcement.
• The school-to-prison pipeline: Suspension can become a gateway to more serious involvement with the justice system, perpetuating a cycle of disadvantage.
• Disciplinary alternatives: Implementing alternative disciplinary approaches can help break this cycle and support students in developing positive behavior strategies. The impact of school suspension and juvenile justice involvement is a critical area for reform.

Inequitable Application of School Suspensions

School suspensions are not applied equitably across all student populations. Significant disparities exist based on race and socioeconomic status.

Racial and Socioeconomic Disparities

Minority students and those from low-income families are disproportionately suspended compared to their peers:

• Statistics demonstrating the disparities: Research consistently reveals a racial bias in school discipline, with minority students facing harsher penalties.
• Discussion of implicit bias in disciplinary practices: Implicit biases within the school system contribute to the overrepresentation of minority students in suspension data. Addressing school suspension disparities requires a critical examination of systemic inequities.

The Need for Restorative Justice Practices

To address the inequities and negative impacts of traditional school suspensions, restorative justice practices offer a promising alternative:

• Examples of restorative justice practices: Restorative circles, conflict mediation, and peer mediation focus on repairing harm and building community.
• Benefits of these approaches: These practices promote positive relationships, teach conflict resolution skills, and foster a sense of belonging within the school community.
• Positive outcomes for students: Studies show that restorative justice can reduce suspensions and improve student behavior and academic performance. Implementing restorative justice in schools offers a powerful way to create more equitable and supportive learning environments.

Conclusion

School suspensions have demonstrably detrimental effects on students' academic achievement, social-emotional well-being, and exacerbate existing inequities in education. We have shown that school suspensions are a harmful disciplinary practice that contributes to negative outcomes and disproportionately impacts marginalized communities. Let's work together to replace harmful school suspensions with evidence-based strategies that support student success and well-being. By advocating for and implementing alternatives to school suspension, we can create safer, more equitable, and supportive learning environments for all students. Reducing school suspensions is not just about changing discipline; it's about investing in the future of our students.