The Best John Wick Movie Has The Worst Rotten Tomatoes Score? A Critical Analysis

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on May 07, 2025

4.2

Share

The John Wick franchise, known for its stylish gun-fu, intricate world-building, and compelling protagonist, has captivated audiences worldwide. Each film has garnered significant praise, but the Rotten Tomatoes scores present a curious anomaly. While all films have performed well, John Wick: Chapter 2 sits notably lower than its predecessors and successor, sparking debate amongst fans and critics alike. This article aims to unravel this paradox and offer a more nuanced understanding of the film's critical reception.

John Wick: Chapter 2 – The Underdog with a Cult Following

Analyzing the Rotten Tomatoes Score

John Wick: Chapter 2 currently holds a 71% rating on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, noticeably lower than John Wick (86%), John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum (90%), and John Wick: Chapter 4 (95%). The critical consensus highlights the film's impressive action sequences but points to a slightly weaker narrative compared to its predecessors. This, however, sits in stark contrast to its widespread adoration among fans.

Exploring the Elements that Make it a Fan Favorite

Many fans cite Chapter 2 as their favorite for several key reasons:

• Improved Action Choreography: The fight sequences in Chapter 2 are frequently lauded as the most innovative and creative in the series. The infamous hallway fight showcases a heightened level of precision and brutality, setting a new standard for action filmmaking. Keywords like "gun-fu," "action sequences," and "fight choreography" are constantly used in online discussions surrounding this film.

• Deeper Exploration of the John Wick Universe: Chapter 2 significantly expands the world of the John Wick films, introducing us more fully to the Continental Hotel and its rules, as well as the shadowy High Table. This world-building adds depth and intrigue, enriching the overall experience. The introduction of new locations, like the Roman amphitheater and the Cassian's hidden fortress, further showcases the scope and detail of this intricate universe.

• Introduction of Key Characters: The introduction of characters like Cassian (Common) and Sofia (Halle Berry), along with their distinct fighting styles and compelling backstories, adds significant layers to the narrative. These characters contribute to the memorable action sequences and leave a lasting impact on the viewers.

• More Intricate Plot: While critics might have pointed to a slightly weaker narrative, many fans appreciate the increased complexity of the plot in Chapter 2. The increased stakes and introduction of new adversaries and allies contribute to a more engaging and suspenseful viewing experience. Terms like "narrative complexity" and "plot intricacy" are often used to praise this aspect.

• Stronger Character Development for John Wick: Chapter 2 delves deeper into John Wick's motivations and past, further humanizing him and enriching the emotional core of the story. This is key to understanding his unwavering dedication and resilience.

Comparing the Critical Reception Across the Franchise

Rotten Tomatoes Scores and Audience Scores

It's crucial to examine both critics' scores and audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes. While the critics' scores show a clear trend of increasing positive reception across the franchise, the audience scores largely mirror this trend showing that the audience and critics largely agree on the overall quality of the movies. The divergence between critics and audience scores for Chapter 2 is less pronounced than the critical score might suggest.

Evolution of the Franchise's Style and Tone

The John Wick franchise has undergone a clear evolution, progressing from a grounded revenge thriller in the first film to a more expansive and increasingly over-the-top action spectacle in subsequent entries. This evolution in action, story, and character development is a natural progression for a successful franchise and must be considered when comparing films. Key terms for this discussion include "action evolution," "narrative progression," "character development," and "franchise evolution."

The Subjectivity of Film Criticism

Film criticism, inherently subjective, involves individual interpretation and personal biases. What one critic finds compelling, another might find underwhelming. Rotten Tomatoes scores, while useful, should be considered alongside individual reviews and, importantly, audience reactions. The reliance on aggregate scores is itself a topic of debate. Considering "critical subjectivity," "film review bias," and "audience perception" helps to contextualize the Rotten Tomatoes scores.

Why John Wick: Chapter 2's Low Score Doesn't Reflect its Quality

The Limitations of Aggregate Scores

Relying solely on aggregate scores like Rotten Tomatoes offers an incomplete picture of a film's quality. They don't account for individual preferences or the nuances of a film's impact. Context matters; a film's place within a franchise and its contribution to the franchise's overall narrative arc must be factored in.

Focusing on Specific Strengths

Chapter 2's specific strengths—its innovative action sequences, world-building, character introductions, and plot complexity—make it a standout, even if the aggregate score is lower than others in the franchise. These points are often cited by fans as reasons to consider it the best installment.

The "Cult Classic" Phenomenon

John Wick: Chapter 2, despite its lower Rotten Tomatoes score, has developed a significant cult following. This demonstrates that initial critical reception doesn't always determine long-term appreciation or cultural impact. A film's lasting influence is often determined by word-of-mouth and fan engagement, rather than simply a numerical score.

Conclusion

This analysis shows that John Wick: Chapter 2's lower Rotten Tomatoes score doesn't negate its quality or its position as a fan favorite. The subjective nature of film criticism, coupled with the limitations of aggregate scores, underscores the importance of considering multiple perspectives. The film's contributions to the franchise's world-building, action innovation, and character development cement its place as a pivotal entry in the series.

What's your pick for the best John Wick movie, and does its Rotten Tomatoes score match your opinion? Let's discuss!